BLURB
BOOK LINKS π
AMAZON | GOODREADS | STORYGRAPH
![]() |
| Finn my favorite MMC |
![]() |
| Finn, Penelope, Grey and Bastian |
REVIEW
False Legacies by Amy BriarMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
BOOK: False Legacies by Amy Briar [Format: eARC]
This debut novel was a nice change to the normal Romantasy tropes—a mix of Dark Academia with Trials set to test skills and build alliances to choose the next leaders of each of the five Houses.
Series: Unknown
Series No: [#1]
Status: Read
Rating: [4.5/5 ⭐]
Page Count: [582 Pages]
QUICK IMPRESSION
The story starts on the eve of a ball. Juliette, the favorite twin and heir to the Grimsorrow legacy, is announced to be betrothed to Bastian Hawthorne—until she is poisoned. Penelope is quickly ordered by her parents to take her sister's place in the Trials in secret to keep their House from looking weak.
QUICK NOTES
• Penelope was a bit of a wild child compared to the demure and poised Juliette. She had swapped places with her sister as a young child, but even so, Penelope was at such a handicap with her parents keeping them separate. I did wonder why the parents wouldn't have considered training both twins, but then we wouldn't have a story, would we? π
• The Trials start with the reader feeling the stress of Penelope having to mingle with the latest class of Legacy Heirs as they gather to create alliances for the Legacy Trials and future political gain. Penelope is navigating all of this with a stacked deck: her powers are unbound, whereas the others are bound and have been training for three years. On top of that, she's investigating who poisoned her sister.
• The pace sharpens dramatically the moment the Trials get underway. I thought they were very well written, and I could really imagine what was happening throughout these different scenarios.
• The Spice... Love Square? We have Juliette's betrothed, Bastian, and then there's Finn and Grey. It certainly gives major tension, mind games, and plenty of chemistry between them all. I really didn't like Bastian at first, but he grew on me as the book progressed. Finn was my favorite, and Grey... well, let's just say π€ you will have to go read and make your own decisions! ππ€―
• The reader is pulled alongside Penelope (posing as Juliette) into a treacherous cycle of secrets, political scheming, fractured loyalties, and unexpected twists... boy, are there some twists.
(view spoiler)
QUOTES TO KEEP
“This evening marks the first formal celebration of the Legacy Trials. A gathering not of families or Houses, but of duty and what the High Realm asks of those who would shape its future.” -Chancellor Vale.
“It’s easier for them. They can shrug it off, turn rumour into bravado. Perhaps they’re even praised for it, envied or admired. A man enjoys himself and it’s expected. A woman does, and she’s either a scandal or a joke. If I lean into the rumours, I’m indecent. If I deny them, I’m frigid and a liar.” - Penelope.
“Grimsorrow!” he exclaims, as though greeting an old friend. “You’re looking exceptionally beautiful this morning. Forced social games suit you.” - Finn.
KEY CHARACTERS
• [Penelope Grimsorrow]: [House Grimsorrow/Legacy Spare]. Power - Shadowbinding (able to create shields, or use the shadows to trap or hide). Her Shadowbinding is unbound, and magic without an anchor is harder to control. Penelope is Juliette's twin—the spare, basically discarded as unnecessary and taught needlepoint! (Although that's not all she gets up to π).
• [Juliette Grimsorrow]: [House Grimsorrow/Legacy Heir]. Her parents ensured she got all the training and benefits, until the night of the Ball when she is found poisoned.
The Romance Interests:
• [Finn Winchester]: [House Solareth/Legacy Heir]. Power - Lightbinding (Illusion). His personality makes him hard not to like—he treats our FMC with respect and has a teasing humor. The life of the party. He was my favorite.
• [Bastian Hawthorne]: [House Wolfgarde/Legacy Heir]. Power - Forcebinding (telekinesis). He is reserved and comes across as grumpy, but once you get to know him, he's easy to warm up to. He definitely puts his House first; the political marriage with Juliette is something he doesn't want, though loyalty to his House had him complying.
• [Grey Deveraux]: [House Loxfell/Legacy Heir]. Power - Temperbinding (manipulation of emotions). He comes across as arrogant and is definitely the morally grey MMC. With a power like that, it's easy to wonder when he is actually being authentic.
(There are more, but these are the main characters.)
FINAL THOUGHTS
• The Good: The worldbuilding was a bit like a cross between a Victorian estate and an exclusive academy with Trials, which were interesting and written in a vivid style so that I could easily visualize the scenes. While the pacing slowed down in between games, it matched the atmosphere well and gave us some light moments to reset and recenter. The plot twists kept me on my toes!
• The Bad (not bad per se, just things that made me question): I would have liked more information on the social structure. The Compact Council (the name really confused me; it didn't make sense as a governing body title) gets a brief history of how it was formed and why, which intrigued me, so I hope we get more in future books! Also, Penelope often found herself losing control of her emotions and reverting to her true self—often in the presence of Grey. I wanted to shout at her to be cautious, though it made me wonder if Grey was the reason given his powers. The author definitely had me doubting my conclusions a lot—which is a GOOD THING.
• Verdict: Oh, the ending! I really can't say much about it without spoiling the book, but I definitely need Book 2! I thoroughly enjoyed this read, and for a debut novel, it shows huge promise for an interesting world. The political aspect of the story arc could really build into something big, and I hope the author has the sequel waiting in the wings soon!
I received a complimentary advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
View all my reviews







































